Shy's Original Steak House

There is a short list of restaurants in Buffalo, New York that achieve true legendary status — places so good that people plan their visits around them, pack them in carry-on luggage, and drive or fly hours to get there. Shy's Original Steak House on Fillmore Avenue is firmly on that list.

With over 800 reviews and a 4.4-star average, Shy's has earned its reputation one perfectly seasoned steak hoagie at a time. The subs here are built with care — steak that's well-seasoned and tender, the right balance of toppings, and a signature sauce that guests rave about. Fair warning: they are famously messy. That's part of the experience, and guests wouldn't have it any other way.

Owner Aisha runs a tight, welcoming ship. First-time visitors from out of town consistently mention how friendly and personal the experience feels — this is a neighborhood institution that treats everyone like a regular. The shop is cash only, no reservations, and operates out of a no-frills setup with a drink machine in the back stocked with bottled beverages.

One regular famously described packing 10 steak hoagies into an empty carry-on to bring home to family in Alabama. Another guest called it "the best steak hoagie in the United States" and mused about franchising it to Tampa. That level of devotion tells you everything you need to know. If you're in Buffalo, Shy's is non-negotiable.